Are Biodiversity Credits the Key to Slowing Down Species Loss?
What are biodiversity credits and can they actually help stem species loss?
Biodiversity refers to the variety of life on Earth, encompassing ecosystem, species, and genetic diversity. However, the alarming reality is that biodiversity is under severe threat. A 2019 report by the United Nations indicated that roughly one-eighth of all estimated species are at risk of extinction1.
The 2022 Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework saw 196 countries vow to reverse biodiversity loss by 20302. Despite this global commitment to halt biodiversity loss, significant funding gaps persist. According to a study by the Nature Conservancy, there is over a $700 billion shortfall between what is spent on conserving nature and what is allocated to activities that harm it3.
Alarmingly, the 2024 Living Planet Index revealed a staggering 73% decline in average wildlife populations since 19704. As the majority of funding for conservation efforts comes from governments, there is a growing call for private sector involvement. This is where biodiversity credits enter the conversation. These credits may offer a way to increase funding for nature conservation projects, helping to stem biodiversity loss. However, critics argue that these credits may not effectively contribute to meaningful improvements in biodiversity.
What Causes Biodiversity Loss?
Biodiversity loss has accelerated at an alarming rate in recent years, primarily as a result of human activities5, including:
Land Use Changes: Deforestation, monoculture agriculture, and urbanization significantly contribute to biodiversity loss. For example, large portions of the Amazon rainforest (considered one of the most biodiverse regions on earth) have been destroyed to make way for cattle ranches6.
Pollution: Contaminants from industrial, agricultural, and urban sources degrade habitats and harm species. Plastic pollution, industrial runoff, and acidification negatively impact aquatic ecosystems, leading to biodiversity loss.
Climate Change: Altering weather patterns and shifting habitats further endanger species. Warming temperatures can make certain species more vulnerable to disease, leading to higher mortality rates7.
These factors disrupt the intricate web of interdependencies among species, leading to cascading effects on ecosystems and the services they provide, which are vital for human survival.
So, What Are Biodiversity Credits?
Biodiversity credits are a financial mechanism designed to promote biodiversity conservation. They allow companies and organizations to purchase credits that fund activities aimed at boosting, protecting, or preserving biodiversity. Essentially, when a company buys a biodiversity credit, the funds are allocated to projects that deliver net gains for biodiversity.
For instance, in 2020, ClimateTrade and Terrasos launched a program to conserve 340 hectares of the Bosque de Niebla, a uniquely biodiverse region in the High Andes of Colombia, funded through biodiversity credits which were sold for approximately $35 each8. As interest in biodiversity credits has grown, they are increasingly seen as a viable way for private companies to contribute to biodiversity efforts.
The Case for Biodiversity Credits
Biodiversity credits are highlighted in the global biodiversity framework as a potential solution to help close the funding gap for nature preservation. Here are some key benefits:
Funding Conservation Projects: By purchasing credits, companies can fund projects that help preserve natural areas and enhance biodiversity.
Enhanced Corporate Image: Companies can improve their public profile and marketing by contributing to biodiversity initiatives, independent of their own operations.
Compensating for Environmental Harm: Biodiversity credits allow businesses to compensate for residual harm in a like-for-like manner, meaning that the credits can fund remediation efforts in similar ecosystems to where the harm occurred.
Investment in Supply Chains: Companies can invest in projects that enhance biodiversity and resilience within their supply chains, making them more sustainable.
Nature-Positive Outcomes: By effectively using biodiversity credits, some companies could transition towards becoming “nature-positive,” where their activities actively enhance biodiversity rather than merely mitigating negative impacts9.
But Wait, Didn’t We Just Do This for Carbon?
The concept of biodiversity credits operates in a similar manner to carbon credits, leading to concerns regarding their efficacy. The carbon credit system has faced criticism for its shortcomings, such as lack of measurable impact and potential for exploitation. Some critics feel that biodiversity credits may face similar issues. Additionally, biodiversity is inherently complex, making it difficult to assess the true impact of biodiversity credits.
To ensure the successful implementation of biodiversity credit systems, robust oversight and guidelines are necessary. Companies should approach biodiversity credits as part of a broader sustainability strategy, not as a standalone solution.
The Future of Biodiversity Credits
For biodiversity credits to be effective, a well-regulated framework must be established. Clear guidelines and oversight will be essential to ensure that the credit market operates transparently and achieves real biodiversity benefits. This includes:
Standardizing Measurement Metrics: Developing consistent metrics for measuring biodiversity impacts will enhance accountability and effectiveness.
Regulatory Oversight: A regulatory body could oversee the biodiversity credit market, ensuring that projects funded through credits are genuinely beneficial to biodiversity.
Stakeholder Engagement: Involving local communities and stakeholders in project development and execution will help ensure that initiatives are relevant and effective.
Conclusion
Biodiversity credits represent a promising financial tool to address the alarming decline in biodiversity. By enabling private sector investment in conservation efforts, these credits could help close the funding gap and foster a more sustainable future. However, to be effective, they must be implemented within a robust regulatory framework that ensures genuine benefits to biodiversity. As we strive to reverse the current trends of species loss, biodiversity credits could play a vital role in preserving the variety of life on Earth for future generations.
While the concept of biodiversity credits is not without its challenges, their potential to contribute positively to biodiversity conservation should not be overlooked. With proper implementation and commitment from both the public and private sectors, biodiversity credits could indeed help stem species loss and foster a healthier planet. Brightest is committed to preserving biodiversity and has partnered with the EU Business and Biodiversity Platform to promote sustainable practices and conservation efforts.
This Week in Sustainability is a weekly email from Brightest (and friends) about sustainability and climate strategy. If you’ve enjoyed this piece, please consider forwarding it to a friend or teammate. If you’re reading it for the first time, we hope you enjoyed it enough to consider subscribing. If we can be helpful to you or your organization’s sustainability journey, please be in touch.