Understanding Carbon Neutrality: A Deeper Dive into Carbon Credits, Offsets, and How to Spot Greenwashing
Decoding carbon neutrality: understanding the realities of achieving zero emissions and avoid greenwashing
The term "carbon neutrality" has become increasingly common, but its true meaning and how companies achieve it can be somewhat confusing. Does it imply that these companies emit zero emissions in their operations? Not exactly. Let's delve into the definition of this term and explore how companies are genuinely attaining "carbon neutrality."
What is carbon neutrality?
Carbon neutrality is the state in which the total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions produced by an individual, organization, or entity are reduced to “none” by measures to reduce, capture, or offset an equivalent amount of greenhouse gases from the atmosphere. So let’s say company A is emitting 5,000 tons of CO2 emissions per year, it would be able to claim it is net-zero if it is able to capture or offset 5,000 tons of CO2 emissions. Offsetting essentially involves taking actions or supporting projects that reduce or remove an equivalent amount of GHG emissions to compensate for emissions produced elsewhere, achieving a balance in overall emissions. Below is a simple representation of how this works.
Now that this is clearer. The question you may be wondering is how does this compensation process work and how legitimate is it.
Carbon Offsets
Carbon offsets are a form of compensation for greenhouse gas emissions produced by a particular activity, process, or entity, where an equivalent amount of emissions is reduced, captured, or removed from the atmosphere through investments in environmentally beneficial projects or activities such as reforestation, renewable energy generation, methane capture, or energy efficiency initiatives. Below is an explanation of the different types of offsets available:
Reforestation and Afforestation: The act of planting trees or restoring forests contributes significantly to the absorption of carbon dioxide, effectively reducing greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.
Clean Energy Initiatives: Investments in clean energy sources such as wind or solar power play a pivotal role in decreasing emissions originating from fossil fuels.
Methane Mitigation: Capturing methane gas from sources like landfills and farms prevents it from being released into the atmosphere, curbing its harmful impact.
Enhancing Energy Efficiency: Focusing on enhancing energy efficiency in buildings and factories is another effective strategy for reducing emissions.
Carbon Credits vs. Carbon Offsets
A carbon credit, also called allowance, is a transferable certificate that can either be assigned directly to a source emitting greenhouse gases or put up for sale in auctions, symbolizing the permission to release one ton of carbon dioxide. Companies obtaining these credits can either sell them or present them to a regulatory authority, matching their emissions for a specified timeframe. Through collaborative trading of carbon credits, companies can effectively shrink their carbon footprints.
Though there's a distinction between carbon credits and carbon offsetting, they share a common objective which is to compensate for CO2 emissions that have been emitted.
What are net-zero targets?
Net-zero goals represent corporate commitments to balance the amount of greenhouse gases produced with an equivalent amount offset or eliminated, aiming to reduce the net emitted to zero, thus helping to mitigate the impact of climate change.
This entails a company committing to reduce and offset its emissions by a certain year. For example, Ford, the world’s third-largest car manufacturer, has pledged to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2050.
In their own words, Ford has stated:
"To achieve its goal, Ford will focus on three areas that account for about 95 percent of its CO2 emissions – vehicle use, supply base and company’s facilities."
Despite a significant 40% increase in the number of companies setting such targets, as revealed by Net Zero Tracker, there are concerns over the credibility and alignment of these targets. When looking into Forbes Global 2000 list, Net Zero Tracker reports a rise in company net-zero targets from 702 to 1,003 within a 16-month span, expanding the coverage of net-zero targets to companies with a collective annual revenue of $27 trillion.
Nevertheless, the reports highlights a pressing need for the integrity of these corporate targets to improve; with only 37% addressing Scope 3 emissions and a mere 13% indicating responsible use of offsets. Astonishingly, only 4% of these targets meet the 'starting line criteria' set by the UN's Race to Zero campaign.
“While most companies set net-zero pledges with good intentions, many of the pledges are still based on self-defined emission boundaries and scope and thus not aligned with the global net-zero emission goal of the Paris Agreement,” Takeshi Kuramochi, senior climate policy researcher at NewClimate Institute
Spotting Greenwashing
As we collectively strive for a greener future, it becomes imperative to remain vigilant against greenwashing—a practice where companies or organizations make false or exaggerated claims about their commitment to the environment.
The European Parliament has taken a decisive step against greenwashing by moving to prohibit environmental claims about carbon neutrality that rely solely on carbon offsetting schemes. This measure has significant implications for how businesses, particularly in the sustainability sector, advertise and label their products. This regulation has already pushed high-profile brands like Gucci, H&M, and Zara to adjust their strategies, moving away from certain 'sustainable' collections and carbon-neutral claims.
With the European Union (EU) Green Claims Directive, terms like 'net zero' and 'eco-friendly' will require substantial verification to be used in marketing. In the UK, the ASA (Advertising Standards Authority) has also updated its guidance, demanding more precise communication about how businesses reduce or offset their carbon emissions. The U.S. is also revisiting its Green Guides to prevent misleading environmental advertising.
Brands now must navigate the complexities of truthful advertising without overstating their environmental efforts. Companies such as Delta Airlines, for example, have faced legal action for making unsubstantiated claims, and others are rethinking their net-zero timelines or abandoning offsetting altogether.
For consumers to discern genuine sustainable practices from greenwashing, here are some tips you can use:
Look for Specifics: Avoid vague claims like 'eco-friendly' and look for specific information about how the product impacts the environment.
Check for Third-Party Verification: Look for environmental claims that have been verified by reputable third-party organizations like the Science-Based Target Initiative (SBTi)
Research the Company's Sustainability Practices: Investigate whether the company's overall practices align with their advertised sustainability efforts.
Be Skeptical of Carbon Offsetting Claims: Understand that offsets are supplementary to actual emissions reductions, not a replacement.
Educate Yourself on Sustainability Terms: Know what different terms mean and what standards they should meet to not be misled by marketing.
Demand Transparency: Support companies that are open about their production processes, supply chains, and the real impact of their products.
In conclusion, carbon neutrality represents the pursuit of a balanced environmental equation through emissions reduction and the use of carbon credits and offsets. As we navigate this path toward a more sustainable future, it is equally relevant to remain vigilant against greenwashing as brands may utilize their claims as marketing strategy.
This Week in Sustainability is a weekly email from Brightest (and friends) about sustainability and climate strategy. If you’ve enjoyed this piece, please consider forwarding it to a friend or teammate. If you’re reading it for the first time, we hope you enjoyed it enough to consider subscribing. If we can be helpful to you or your organization’s sustainability journey, please be in touch.